Sazetak

×

Error message

  • Deprecated function: Function create_function() is deprecated in views_php_handler_field->pre_render() (line 202 of /home/logosorg/public_html/modules/views_php/plugins/views/views_php_handler_field.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Function create_function() is deprecated in views_php_handler_area->render() (line 39 of /home/logosorg/public_html/modules/views_php/plugins/views/views_php_handler_area.inc).
Logos - časopis za filozofiju i religiju, Vol. 10, br. 1, 2022
The Bosnian national issue within the boundaries of dual and subnational identity
UDK/UDC:
323.1(497.6)
Autor
Enver Halilović

 

Abstract:
 

Compared to many other countries and nations, the Bosnian issue has the longest history. It has been taking place continuously from the Ottoman, through Austro-Hungarian, and the two Yugoslav periods all the way to the present day. What gives hope for its resolution today is that the main world power, the USA, is establishing political and social relations on the principles of liberalism and human rights, such that a new solution to this issue will be found within these frameworks, and not within ethnopolitical frameworks, as it has been unsuccessfully contemplated and pursued by Europe and Russia.

The fundamental principles of the political Serbo-Croatian contestation of Bosnia, Bosniaks and Bosnians are a combination of historical, cultural, religious, political and economic factors of its past, from the earliest times of its existence until today. Some say everything is Serbian there and that's why it's pan-Serbian, and others say everything is Croatian and that's why it's pan-Croatian. The purpose of these two ideologies individually and together is the denationalization of Bosniaks/Bosnians and the ontological desubstantialization and destatization of the state of Bosnia, both throughout history and today. However, their mutual exclusivity over Bosnia confirms that both are untrue and a priori constructions.

The political past and present of Bosnia, in its essence, depends on the West. However, while the West is fighting against the idea of a Russian world in Ukraine, at the same time, it supports the idea of a Croatian world and a Serbian world in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Some time ago, it formed the RS on the wings of the doctrine of the Serbian world, just as today, through changes in the electoral law of BH, it supports the ethnocentric doctrine of the Croatian world in Bosnia and Herzegovina. However, if Russia loses the war in Ukraine, not only in the military sense, but also in the political sense, if it loses the status of a world political power, then a completely different political future of the Western Balkans can be expected. However, the question is whether the West will want to do that for its own sake.

Bosnian national identity is established on the values and the characteristics common to all Bosnians and Herzegovinians, all ethnic communities, and all citizens of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Common Bosnian values are numerous and diverse, but they are still in a serious historical political crisis. This is not specific to Bosnia at all, due to the administrative-political imposition and dominance of the dual national identities of Serbs and Croats in Bosnia and Herzegovina, on one hand, and the subnational identity of Bosniaks on the other. However, under the influence of factors that produce crises of national political identities, such as: modernization, economic development and urbanization, there is a weakening of the dual national identities of Serbs and Croats and the subnational identity of Bosniaks, on one hand, and the strengthening of the civic national identity of Bosnia and Herzegovina, on the other.
 

Keywords: Bosnian political issue, civic national identity, dual national identity, subnational identity

 

Bosansko nacionalno pitanje u granicama dvojnih i podnacionalnog identiteta
UDK/UDC:
323.1(497.6)
Autor
Enver Halilović, Filozofski fakultet, Univerzitet u Tuzli

 

Abstract:
 

U poređenju sa mnogim drugim državama i narodima Bosansko pitanje ima najdugotrajniju historiju. Odvija se u kontinuitetu od otomanskog, austrougarskog, preko dva jugoslavenska perioda do danas. Ono što budi nadu u njegovom rješavanju danas jeste da glavna svjetska sila, SAD, postavljaju političke i društvene odnose na principima liberalizma i ljudskih prava,  te da će novo rješenje ovog pitanja biti nađeno u tim okvirima, a ne u etnopolitičkim okvirima kako su ga do sada neuspješno tražile i postavljale Evropa i Rusija.

Fundamentalne postavke političkog srpskohrvatskog osporavanja Bosne, Bošnjaka i Bosanaca su  kombinacija historijskih, kulturnih, vjerskih, političkih i ekonomskih činilaca njene prošlosti, od najstarijih vremena njenog postojanja do danas. Jedni kažu sve je tamo srpsko i zato je tamo svesrpstvo, a drugi kažu sve je tamo hrvatsko i zato je to svehrvatstvo. Svrha ovih dviju ideologija pojedinačno i zajedno je denacionalizacija Bošnjaka/Bosanaca i ontološka desupstancijalizacija i deetatizacija države Bosne, kako kroz povijest/istoriju tako i danas. Međutim, njihova međusobna isključivost oko Bosne potvrđuje da su obje neistinite i apriorističke konstrukcije.

Politička prošlost i sadašnjost Bosne, u osnovi, zavisi od Zapada. Ali, Zapad, u isto vrijeme, dok se bori protiv ideje ruskog svijeta u Ukrajini, podržava ideju hrvatskog svijeta i srpskog sveta u BiH. On je svojevremeno formirao RS na krilima doktrine srpskog sveta, kao što danas promjenama izbornog zakona BiH podržava etnocentričku doktrinu hrvatskog svijeta u BiH. Međutim, ako Rusija izgubi rat u Ukrajini, ne samo u vojnom, već i u političkom smislu, ako izgubi status svjetske političke sile, onda je za očekivati potpuno politički drugačiju budućnost Zapadnog Balkana. Međutim, pitanje je da li će Zapad htjeti da to učini zbog sebe.

Bosanski nacionalni identitet zasniva se na vrijednostima i svojstvima koja su zajednička svim bosancima i hercegovcima, svim etničkim zajednicama, svim građanima BiH. Zajedničke bosanske vrijednosti i karakteristike su brojne i raznovrsne, ali su još u ozbiljnoj historijskoj političkoj krizi, što nije nikakva bosanska specifičnost, zbog toga što su administrativno-politički nametnuti i dominiraju dvojni nacionalni identiteti Srba i Hrvata u BiH, na jednoj, i podnacionalni identitet Bošnjaka u BiH, na drugoj strani. Međutim, pod uticajem uzroka koji proizvode krize nacionalnih političkih identiteta, kao što su: modernizacija, ekonomski razvoj i urbanizacija, dolazi i do slabljenja dvojnih nacionalnih identiteta Srba i Hrvata i podnacionalnog identiteta Bošnjaka, na jednoj, i jačanja državljanskog nacionalnog identiteta BiH i Bosanaca, na drugoj strani.
 

Ključne riječi: bosansko političko pitanje, državljanski nacionalni identitet, dvojni nacionalni identitet, podnacionalni identitet